Locally Owned & Operated

100% Satisfaction Guaranteed

Switch Location
2120 W. College Ave.
Appleton, WI 54914

We're looking to hire!

Glass Nickel Pizza - Appleton is looking to round out our crews. Click now for openings.

Growing Green

Here at the Glass Nickel Pizza Co.®, we have implemented a variety of eco-friendly devices into our business. From ovens that turn off when not in use to cars that run on used vegetable oil, we are taking steps to reduce our dependance on our natural resources.

In Pizza We Trust®

A Pizza For Everyone - From Our Delicious Bacon, Broccoli & Wedge Fry Couch Potato to Our Famous Fetalicious® We Have What You Crave  - Check Out Our Menu!

Order Online

Online ordering is fast and easy!  With a simple to navigate menu, all you need to do is choose what you want and our Chefs will begin cooking your order right away. 

Need to feed a lot of people without spending a lot of dough?  Give Glass Nickel Catering a try.  From pans of our delicious lasagna to freshly made sandwiches, we have something to please everyone.

Franchise Opportunities

Looking to Start a New Career Path?  Maybe We Can Help . . .

Pizza of the Month

Whistle Stop

Whistle Stop. Book your holiday season with this tremendously tasty tomato delight. Featuring pesto, tomatillos, tomato filets and a seasoned bread crumb mix topped with mozzarella and shredded parmesan. This soon to be storied pie is available November and December only.

Seasonal Dessert

Bourbon Pecan Pie

Bourbon Pecan Pie: Take a decadent, southern style pecan pie with shortbread crust and liven up the flavor with an infusion of Kentucky bourbon. Oh my. Delicious and indulgent, pour yourself into a slice of spirited bliss! $6.95

Seasonal Favorite

Fried Green Beans

Fried Green Beans: Crisp, Grade A petite whole green beans coated with a mouth watering toasted onion batter. Paired with a side of savory Cajun rémoulade to combine for a southern twist on everyone's favorite holiday side dish. Cool beans, y’all! $6.95